The Harmony of Complexity:Can There Be Too Many Parts in a “Classical” Composition?

As a foreword - This was originally written about concert band music, but it can apply to choral, orchestral (of any type), rock and other kinds of music. Also, this article will focus on what is commonly called classical music, although it’s used to describe any type of serious music. 

In the realm of music composition, the question of how many different parts should be included in a classical composition is one that has sparked debate for generations. Should a composition be richly layered with numerous instruments, each playing a unique role, or should it strive for simplicity, with fewer parts ensuring clarity and precision? This debate, while complex, is fundamental to the world of music. In this opinion piece, we will explore the various facets of this discussion and consider whether there can indeed be too many different parts in a classical composition. 

Origins of Multi-Part Music 

In the early years of the Middle Ages, two types of vocal music were dominant, the Gregorian and Gallican chant, both used primarily for Christian worship. There was a limited amount of instrumental music written during that period, mainly for woodwinds like the flute, pan flute, and recorder; string instruments like the lute, dulcimer, psaltery, and zither; and brass instruments like the sackbut (similar to the modern trombone). Troubadours would accompany themselves on a simple stringed instrument such as a lute or psaltery.  In later years, a form of music known as organum was introduced. It was two melodic lines moving simultaneously, sometimes creating an imaginary chord. Sometimes a second, or organal, voice doubled the principal voice at an interval of a fourth or a fifth below. It was for both vocal and instrumental music. This method increased the likelihood of creating a true chord. During this time, the church imposed strict rules about what kinds of musical devices could or couldn’t be used. For example, all music in the church was to be in triple meter. As time passed, more parts were added and the rules were ignored or removed. Some of the resulting music was extremely complex and sometimes, as in vocal music, unintelligible to the listener, though beautiful to listen to. Soon, some composers and musicians started asking themselves, “How many parts is too many”? 

The Beauty of Complexity 

One argument in favor of composing with a multitude of parts is the richness and depth it can bring to a piece of music. In the hands of a skilled composer, a concert band with a wide array of instruments can create a sonic tapestry that is both intricate and captivating. This complexity allows for a broader palette of sounds, enabling composers to convey a wide range of emotions and moods within a single composition. 

Moreover, the beauty of complexity in music lies in its ability to surprise and engage the listener. When numerous instruments interweave and interact, it can lead to moments of revelation and excitement. Each part contributes to the overall texture, and the audience may find themselves discovering new nuances with each listening. 

The Challenge of Balance 

However, the proponents of simplicity argue that too many different parts can lead to a lack of clarity and coherence in a concert band composition. Balancing a multitude of instruments, each with its own unique timbre and role, can be a daunting task for a composer. If not managed effectively, the result can be a cacophony rather than a harmonious piece of music. 

Furthermore, a composition with too many parts can overwhelm the musicians themselves. It requires a high level of skill and coordination to execute such pieces successfully. Inexperienced or less proficient musicians may struggle to keep up, leading to a performance that falls short of the composer's intentions. 

The Listener's Perspective 

Ultimately, the success of a classical composition is often measured by the experience it provides to the listener. From the listener's perspective, the question becomes: does the complexity of a composition enhance or detract from their enjoyment? 

For some, the challenge of unraveling intricate compositions is part of the allure of classical music. They revel in the layers of sound and the puzzle of identifying each instrument's contribution. In this sense, complexity is not a barrier but an invitation to deeper engagement. 

Conversely, others may find themselves overwhelmed by compositions with too many parts. They long for the simplicity and clarity that comes with fewer instruments. To them, music should communicate directly and immediately, without requiring exhaustive analysis. 

Finding the Balance 

So, can there be too many different parts in a classical composition? The answer is not a definitive yes or no but rather a matter of balance and intent. The key lies in the composer's ability to harness complexity without sacrificing clarity and in the performer's proficiency to execute the composition faithfully. 

It's essential for composers to approach complexity with a clear artistic vision. Each instrument and part should have a purpose within the composition, contributing to the overall narrative or emotional expression. In this way, complexity becomes a tool for artistic expression rather than an end in itself. 

In the case of vocal music, it may be wise to err on the side of simplicity so that the words can be understood; it is, after all, the main reason for writing a vocal piece. For instrumental music, a severely complex piece may depict the very emotion or message that the composer wants to present. For the sake of good art, it should resolve itself at some point. 

Additionally, performers must be up to the challenge presented by complex compositions. Rehearsal, precision, and a deep understanding of the composer's intentions are crucial in ensuring that the richness of the music shines through without becoming overwhelming. 

Conclusion 

In the world of classical composition, the debate over the number of parts a piece should have will likely continue. While some composers will continue to craft intricate and multi-layered compositions, others will opt for simplicity and clarity. Both approaches have their merits and can create deeply moving and memorable music. 

Ultimately, the beauty of music lies in its diversity. There is no one-size-fits-all answer to whether there can be too many different parts in a classical composition. Instead, the measure of a composition's success lies in its ability to connect with its audience, whether through complexity or simplicity, and to convey the composer's artistic vision effectively. 

Salt Cellar Creations understands the diversity that music can express and has a professional, growing library of original works and arrangements done in simple and complex ways. Explore the offerings HERE. 

SCC can also create an original piece for you or do a custom arrangement for you that will showcase your ensemble. There are two ways that this can be done; one is much more affordable than the other. And SCC is always looking for ideas of pieces to arrange or suggestions for original pieces.

We have sold music not only in the US but in Canada, the United Kingdom, France, Australia, and New Zealand. Please CONTACT US to let us know what we can do for you!